Not a taking of property to give owners the difference between the foreclosure price and the tax debt rather than the fair market value minus the tax debt
The Supreme Court held in Tyler v. Hennepin County, 598 U.S. 631 (2023), that a municipality must return the amount received in a tax foreclosure sale that exceed the tax debt to the homeowner to avoid causing an unconstitutional taking of property. However, it held in Pung v. Isabella County, 609 U.S. 30 (2026), that it need only hand over the difference between the tax foreclosure sale price and the tax debt not the fair market value of the property minus the sale debt. The Court found this to be the traditional practice and that was all that mattered even though the theory and purpose of the tax foreclosure procedures is to ensure the taxes are paid not to penalize the owner for not paying them. From a practical standpoint, the Court thought an owner of property whose fair market value exceeds the tax debt should be able to get […]
