Not a taking of property to give owners the difference between the foreclosure price and the tax debt rather than the fair market value minus the tax debt

The Supreme Court held in Tyler v. Hennepin County, 598 U.S. 631 (2023), that a municipality must return the amount received in a tax foreclosure sale that exceed the tax debt to the homeowner to avoid causing an unconstitutional taking of property. However, it held in Pung v. Isabella County, 609 U.S. 30 (2026), that it need only hand over the difference between the tax foreclosure sale price and the tax debt not the fair market value of the property minus the sale debt. The Court found this to be the traditional practice and that was all that mattered even though the theory and purpose of the tax foreclosure procedures is to ensure the taxes are paid not to penalize the owner for not paying them. From a practical standpoint, the Court thought an owner of property whose fair market value exceeds the tax debt should be able to get […]

Not a taking of property to give owners the difference between the foreclosure price and the tax debt rather than the fair market value minus the tax debt Read More »

Wyoming law interprets a conveyance to “husband and wife” as a tenancy by the entirety

A state statute in Wyoming, Wyo. §34-1-140, provides that any conveyance to “husband and wife,” “spouses” or similar language creates a tenancy by the entirety, not a tenancy in common and not a joint tenancy. The Wyoming Supreme Court in Lewis v. Wolfe, 2026 WY 63, 590 P.3d 1221 (Wyo. 2026), held that the statute applies retroactively since the statute provides that it is “intended as a clarification of existing Wyoming law.”

Wyoming law interprets a conveyance to “husband and wife” as a tenancy by the entirety Read More »

Landlord held not liable under Virginia law for negligently harming tenant when the harm resulted from a failure to correct a defect that the landlord knew about

Applying Virginia law, the Fourth Circuit held that landlords are not liable to tenants for harm caused by an omission. In this case, although notified of a leaky skylight, the landlord failed to fix it. When the tenant slipped on water that entered the house through the defective skylight and sued the landlord for negligence, the landlord was held to be immune the landlord had not caused the defect by any affirmative action. Metz v. McCarthy, 167 F.4th 722 (4th Cir. 2026). Note that other jurisdictions reject that view. Hemmings v. Pelham Wood Ltd. Liability Ltd. P’ship, 826 A.2d 443 (Md. 2003); Childs v. Purll, 882 A.2d 227 (D.C. 2005); Goffe v. Pickard, 588 A.2d 265 (D.C. 1991); Gregory v. Fourthwest Invs., Ltd., 754 P.2d 89 (Utah 1988).

Landlord held not liable under Virginia law for negligently harming tenant when the harm resulted from a failure to correct a defect that the landlord knew about Read More »

Deeds are subject to reformation when there is a mutual mistake and they fail to accurately reflect the intent of the parties who created the easement

A deed created an easement in favor of the grantee to access a river from the dominant estate but it was mistakenly worded so that it did not extend all the way to the river. The Iowa Supreme Court affirmed that the easement language in the deed could be reformed to achieve the intent of both parties, especially when subsequent conduct had shown mutual agreement to allow access to the river. Fink v. Lawson, 30 N.W.3d 582 (Iowa 2026). The court explained that the key is to achieve the grantor’s intent although it also focused on the intent of both parties.

Deeds are subject to reformation when there is a mutual mistake and they fail to accurately reflect the intent of the parties who created the easement Read More »

Covenant prohibiting nightclub is reasonable, not against public policy, and enforceable.

The District of Columbia Court of Appeals has rejected a claim that a real covenant prohibiting operation of a nightclub was unreasonable or against public policy. DTLD, LLC v. Power Station Ltd. P’ship, 350 A.3d 1285 (D.C. 2026). The court explained its position that covenants are “disfavored” as “restrictions on the free use of property.” Id. at 1290. At the same time, they “give rise to reasonable expectations.” Id. Despite the conclusion of a city agency that a nightclub could be operated safely without any “undue impact” on the neighboring properties, the test for finding a covenant to be unreasonable requires courts to defer to the wishes of the covenant creators unless the covenant is irrational or causes harm to the public and neither was the case here.

Covenant prohibiting nightclub is reasonable, not against public policy, and enforceable. Read More »

Energy company ordered to remove pipeline when its easement over allotted tribal lands expires

In a case that is both remarkable and routine, the Seventh Circuit has ordered an energy company to remove a pipeline that traverses lands allotted to tribal members once the easement expires. Bad River Band of the Lake Superior Tribe of Chippewa Indians of the Bad River Reservation, 184 F.4th 874 (7th Cir. 2026) In one sense, the case is a routine application of longstanding law that easements are limited uses of the property of another and when an easement has a time limit, the expiration of the allotted time automatically ends rights under the easement. Since the rights under the easement have terminated, further intrusion on the underlying land is a trespass that can be remedied by ejectment. In another sense, the case is notable for treating tribal allotments (which are generally subject to a restraint on alienation) as property that is equally entitled to protection from trespass as

Energy company ordered to remove pipeline when its easement over allotted tribal lands expires Read More »

No summary process for eviction when tenant holds an option to purchase under the lease

The Nebraska Supreme Court has held that a tenant cannot be evicted using summary process procedure when the tenant holds an option to purchase under the terms of the lease and when the lease imposes a restraint on alienation of the property without giving the tenants an opportunity to exercise the option. Martens v. BB’s Childcare, LLC, 34 N.W.3d 393 (Neb. 2026). The court reasoned that the case involved a “title dispute” and that took it outside the ambit of cases governed by the summary process statute, Neb. Rev. Stat. § 25–21,29 et seq. Such cases were governed by a different statute.

No summary process for eviction when tenant holds an option to purchase under the lease Read More »

Personal property can be partitioned

The Supreme Court of Wyoming has held that under Wyoming law, partition is available as a remedy for joint owners of personal property (in this case, cars). Navarro v. Oros-Garcia, 589 P.3d 335 (Wyo. 2026). The court noted that the state partition statute governed partition of real property, not personal property, but that the common law allows partition of personal property. It does so in order to “avoid the inconvenience and dissension arising from the joint possession of property” and also “facilitates transmission of title, thereby avoiding unreasonable restraints on the use and enjoyment of property.” (¶ 15)

Personal property can be partitioned Read More »

Mowing grass & trimming bushes not sufficiently “open and notorious” to justify adverse possession

The Supreme Court of Ohio has held that mowing grass and trimming bushes is not sufficiently “open and notorious” to put a reasonable owner on notice that someone is taking possession of the land. NC Enters., LLC v. Norfolk & W. Ry., 2026 WL 1113731 (Ohio 2026). Some other courts agree. See Siedlik v. Nissen, 931 N.W.2d 439 (Neb. 2019); Warren v. Burnham, 573 P.3d 421 (Or. Ct. App. 2025). The holding is notable since some other courts have found to the contrary. See Union Cemetery Burial Soc’y of N. Smithfield v. Foisy, 292 A.3d 1205 (R.I. 2023); Jutting v. Hendrix, 606 N.W.2d 140, 142 (S.D. 2000). Cf. Ballard v. Harman, 737 N.E.2d 411 (Ind. Ct. App. 2000) (planting 50 trees sufficient to obtain adverse possession). The court justified its ruling by taking the possession that adverse possession is “disfavored” and the requirements to show its various elements “are stringent.”

Mowing grass & trimming bushes not sufficiently “open and notorious” to justify adverse possession Read More »

Washington Supreme Court prohibits private nonjudicial foreclosure when the mortgage note is not a negotiable instrument

After the subprime crisis, some courts became quite strict in their requirements for foreclosures, both nonjudicial and judicial, while other courts were far more lenient in forgiving banks who did not strictly comply with statutory requirements to prove a right to foreclose. A recent case by the Supreme Court of Washington held that the beneficiary of a deed of trust (similar to a mortgage arrangement) could not engage in a private, nonjudicial foreclosure because state law defined the beneficiary entitled to private foreclosure as one who was the “holder” of the promissory note which was the basis of the lien on the property. The Court interpreted the word “holder” in the state foreclosure statute to mean the holder of a negotiable instrument as defined by the Uniform Commercial Code. Since the note in this case was not a negotiable instrument, nonjudicial foreclosure was not available. Certification from the U.S. District.

Washington Supreme Court prohibits private nonjudicial foreclosure when the mortgage note is not a negotiable instrument Read More »

Scroll to Top